Notes for 11/17/2026

  

11/17/2026

 

[Philosophy Club every Wednesday, 5-6 pm, in the Buchtel College of Arts and Sciences room 436 ("The Cave")

Bioethics Club Tuesdays from 4:30-5:30 in CAS 436.]

 

A and B have been married 40 years. B is dying. During years 20-25 of the marriage, A had an affair with B’s best friend, C. Should A confess to B before B dies?


 

Ethics: the use of reason in the service of the good.

 

 

Meta-ethics: the examination of ethical concepts (good, bad, right, wrong, obligation, etc.)

 

“What, exactly, does that mean?”

 

Normative ethics: How do we decide what is right and wrong? (Includes ethical theories)

 

Applied ethics: Are specific types of actions permissible or impermissible. (Include questions like is the use of autonomous weapons systems permissible?)

 

Both normative and applied ethics make use of the other main methodologies from this class:

 

“Why should we do that rather than something else?”

 

“What (moral) difference might it make if we act one way rather than another?”

 

 

What is the difference between ethics and morals?

 

(Generally, the difference is that ethics has to do with objective standards, while morals have to do with subjective values.)

 

However, this distinction is NOT well-preserved in detailed treatments of the topics.

Often ‘moral’ and ‘ethical’ are used interchangeably.

 

Ethical subjectivism (individual relativism)

Ethical objectivism (individual moral judgments can be right or wrong)

Ethical/moral realism (ethical facts exist)

 

It is always more complicated than you think.

 

Universals = what different things have in common

 

 

 

Plato thought that the Forms formed a hierarchy. At the very top of this hierarchy is the Form of the Good. Goodness itself.

 

Whether or not any Form is a “good fit” to anything in the world presupposes the Form of the Good.

 

For Plato, an action will be good to the extent that it matches the Form of the Good.

 

We know whether or not some action is good in respect of the use of reason.

 

 

Neo-Platonism swaps the form of the Good with God.

 

(Reason is a transcendent power of the soul to know the Forms.)

 

 

Plato’s allegory of the cave:

 

Imagine a prisoner who is shackled facing a wall. Behind him is a fire that casts shadows on the wall. The prisoner mistakes the shadows for real things. When freed, the prisoner leaves the cave and sees the sun and other objects daylight.

 

Shadows = objects of the senses.

Shackles = the body

 

Sun = Form of the Good

 

Objects in daylight = Forms seen with the soul (not the senses)

 

 

The Good has its own nature independent of belief, opinion, etc.

 

Central to this model is the view that the Good is known by reason (morality/ethics is known by reason)

 

 

(Oversimplified:) Neo-Platonism replaces the Form of the Good with God.

 

If there is a God, is God a moral realist?

If there is a God, is God a mathematical realist?

 

Theistic voluntarism vs theistic intellectualism

 

“eternal truths’ (necessary truths) e.g. 1+1=2

 

Theistic voluntarists emphasize God’s omnipotence (absolute sovereignty)

-     God created the eternal truths (they are a function of the divine will)

-     God could have made 1+1=3

-     God would have to be a conventionalist

 

Theistic intellectualists emphasize God’s intellect

-     The eternal truths are co-eternal with God because they exist in the divine intellect

-     God could not made mathematical truths different than they are because they exist in the divine intellect which exists necessarily

 

Are moral truths eternal truths?

 

Authoritarian ethics:

Right & wrong are products of some authority who declares what is or is not good/permissible/right

 

An action is right if and only if the action conforms to a rule made by the proper authority

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Notes for 9/10/2026