Notes for 11/12/2026
11/12/2026
[Philosophy Club every Wednesday, 5-6 pm, in the Buchtel College of Arts and Sciences room 436 ("The Cave")
Bioethics Club Tuesdays from 4:30-5:30 in CAS 436.]
Assuming you could change any one of your past choices, would you want to, given that you can’t be sure how a different choice would have turned out?
Is time travel possible?
Is time REAL?
Is the directionality of time real?
What explains the directionality of time?
- Usual answer is given in terms of the “thermodynamic” arrow (or “entropic arrow”)
Causal limitations on time travel
Suppose A brings about B
If time travel is possible into the past, then it would be possible to avoid B by making A not happen.
But B is what brings about your elimination of A.
Causal paradox (best known example = grandfather paradox)
In the Grandfather Paradox, how, exactly, does “chronology protection” work? What, exactly, prevents you from killing your grandfather?
Types of possibility:
Logical possibility (absence of logical contradiction)
Physical possibility (consistency with laws of nature / causal laws)
It isn’t just about grandfathers – more generally, for B to CHANGE A requires both that A happens (in order to be changed) and that it can be made not to happen, in which case it no longer happens in order to be changed.
The “parallel worlds” attempt to solve the grandfather paradox:
When you go back in time, you arrive in a parallel world where you can kill your grandfather in THAT world.
But this isn’t really a solution. It doesn’t solve the problem that led you to go back in time in the first place.
Going into the past to eliminate A results in your only eliminating A*
Time travel into the past IS possible if you don’t change anything at all, but rather only do or bring about what already happened.
Another variation: Suppose you have accepted a 1-way trip into the past. You track down the person who invented the time machine. If you steal a particular book from that person’s library, they will never invent the time machine and you will never have gone back in time. Problem solved?
Time travel into the past might be possible so long as causality is not violated.
So: You go back in time and meet the person who invented the time machine. They haven’t figured out yet how to build it. But there’s a book you know of that could help, so you obtain that book and give it to them making it possible for them to invent the time machine. (No paradox?)
Bootstrap “paradox” (is it really a paradox?)
You want to become rich, so you go back in time bringing with you the plans for the time machine and give them to your earlier self. Now YOU “invent” (copy) the time machine and get rich from it.
Back to the question of the nature of time:
What, exactly, is time?
Time is the measure of change.
Is time possible WITHOUT change?
In the absence of something that changes that can serve as a “clock” there can be no passage of time. For time to pass is for time to pass relative to some changing thing that “measures” (or observes) it.
If all “clocks” were to stop and nothing existed by which the passage of time could be marked, then it makes no sense to talk about time PASSING at all.
Sydney Shoemaker’s frozen regions thought experiment
Suppose the universe was divided into three regions, each of which experiences a “local freeze”
During a local freeze, the frozen region has no changes taking place within it
A local freeze lasts exactly 1 year.
Region A: Experiences a local freeze every 3rd year
Region B: Experiences a local freeze every 4th year
Region C: Experiences a local freeze every 5th year
What happens during year 60?
One answer (that says time is impossible without change) is that there is no such thing as DURING year 60. There is no sense in the suggestion that all regions are frozen for the SAME TIME.
Another answer is that we have good inductive reasons to think that all three regions are frozen for one year.
The second view depends on thinking that time is passing IN a frozen region (measured within it), while the first depends on thinking that time is only passing FOR a frozen region (measured only from outside it – an external vantage point).
If we take the first view, we have to say that the pattern “resets” since there is (and can be) no such thing as a “universal freeze” (because there is no external vantage from which the passage of time can be measured).
The second view holds that there is a difference between measuring the passage of time and the passing of time.
What makes it true that one year has passed?
What could make it true that 1 year has passed rather than 1 second or 1000 years?
Correspondence theory of truth: Truth is correspondence with the facts.
What are the facts that determine HOW MUCH time has passed in this thought experiment?
Analogy:
A B
1 2 3 4 5 6
Suppose we ask “how far apart are A and B?
On the first line, the question makes no sense because we are presupposing a measure of length in the question.
In Shoemaker’s frozen universe scenario, we do the same, only with a measure of duration.
Comments
Post a Comment