Notes for 10/20/2026

  

10/20/2026

 

[Philosophy Club every Wednesday, 5-6 pm, in the Buchtel College of Arts and Sciences room 436 ("The Cave")

Bioethics Club Tuesdays from 4:30-5:30 in CAS 436.]

 

Do you believe animals have souls?


 

What, exactly, is the soul?

 

 

 History of the concept of the soul

 

What is the soul supposed to do?

 

2 primary functions concepts of soul were intended to perform:

 

-     Explain life (difference between living and non-living things) = vitalism (soul = principle of life): something needs to be added to a body to have life

-     Explain cognition/consciousness/reason/self

 

Today, no one in the sciences accepts vitalism

 

The view that the soul explains (or is needed to explain cognition) is now generally called “dualism”

 

Rene Descartes argues that the mind/soul is a distinct substance from the body (and can exist without it):

-     Substance dualism

-     Interactionist dualism

-     Cartesian dualism

-     Mind-body dualism

 

 

Do you think there is a difference between you and your body?

 

 

 

 

What are the arguments for mind-body dualism?

 

Main type of argument:

 

Argument from divergent properties:

 

1.    The mind has properties that the body doesn’t have (or vice versa), i.e., they have divergent properties.

2.    If x and y have divergent properties, then x and y can’t be the same.

3.    Therefore, the mind is not the same as the body.

 

Example: Divisibility

 

 

 

 

Shift from mechanics to function

 

The discovery of the electro-chemical nature of the brain shifts focus away from mechanics

 

The invention of electronic computing (electro-mechanical switches)

A neuron and the basic components of computers work in the same basic way:

Computers are based on on-off switches

Brains are based on firing-nonfiring neurons

 

What is the mind?

 

Dualism (substance dualism): mind = a non-physical entity (=soul) that associates with the body/brain but is distinct from it

 

Main arguments for dualism:

-     Divergent properties arguments (minds and brains/bodies have divergent properties)

-     Appeal to religious belief (non-rational)

-     Appeal to paranormal experiences

 

Identity theory: mind = functioning brain, or rather, every mental state JUST IS a brain state

-     Progress in brain science

 

Functionalism: mind is a function of a brain or analogous information-processing system

(“The mind is what the brain does.” – Marvin Minsky)

-     Thought experiments (multiple-realizability: aliens, individual variation in brain architecture)

-     Progress in artificial intelligence

 

 

Both identity theory and functionalism are physicalist: (they are consistent with the thesis that only physical things exist)

 

Descartes: The foundation of knowledge is INTROSPECTION. (Our minds are like eyes that “look at” our ideas.)

 

The dominant view after Descartes is that to think is to have IDEAS.

 

But what would ideas be, and what, exactly, would THOUGHT be on an identity theory or functionalist view of the mind?

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Notes for 9/10/2026